Speaker's Corner - Junior doctor contracts and why we should all be worried

This month Dr Ben Molyneux gives his views on the junior doctors contract dispute. Ben is a sessional GP and member of City & Hackney LMC. He is also a member of the BMA GP Committee, and previous Chairman of the Junior Doctors Committee.

Junior doctor contracts and why we should all be worried

What’s this about striking?

Waving placards, marching on streets and threats of strike action are activities you might associate with railways workers and students, but not normally with junior doctors. Juniors are usually viewed as a fairly stoic bunch so it has come as a surprise to many, not least the government, that so much anger has erupted over the proposed new contract.

Looking back to when I was involved with the initial negotiations, those were the rosy days of minimal political interference and getting on with the issues. Since then, unfortunately, what could have been an agreeable settlement has turned into a pitched battle.

What’s the problem?

There is plenty of information from the BMA on what the issues are. The headlines are potential pay cuts for many – the BMA pay calculator has shown up to 30% cuts in some cases - and the GP trainee supplement is particularly vulnerable. Pay progression will end, so those who take time out for academic study or parental leave will earn less than their peers. Perhaps worst though, is the loss of safeguards against working excess hours, and a move to make a normal working week anything within 7am-10pm Monday to Saturday. There will be little to prevent the days of tired doctors putting patients at risk coming back to haunt us.

Where are we now?

After the BMA refused to negotiate until the above issues were removed as pre-requisites for discussion, Jeremy Hunt threatened to impose the contract instead. This gun to the head has galvanised juniors in a way I have never witnessed before and we now see protests all around the country, stories in every paper, and even traditionally anti-doctor outlets looking on favourably.

Since the BMA has announced it will ballot the membership for industrial action, over 5,000 new members have signed up as a result. Those wishing to respond to the ballot need to be registered with the BMA by 29 October. A Facebook group has over 51,000 members actively discussing different methods to get the message out to the profession, the public, and to government. There have been multiple protest events, and the biggest of these so far is a march planned for 17 October. This march has been arranged entirely by grassroots juniors in between their shifts and this huge amount of work demonstrates just how strongly people feel.

Why is this important?

You may be reading this thinking, “I’m a GP, I have my own issues to worry about” and that is true, however, I believe this is wider than the junior doctor contract. This is the opening move from government to move all NHS staff onto 7-10, seven days per week rotas for no additional pay. If we don’t support juniors now then nurses, physios and GPs will all be next to see unilateral contract changes to suit the government agenda. We must do all we can to support the juniors, because if we win this battle to see justice for our colleagues and our patients, then maybe, just maybe, they will think twice before they come for us.

I’ll be marching to support juniors on 17 October; I hope to see some of you there.

Last updated : 11 Nov 2015

Data sharing agreement checklist and guidance for practices (21 Aug 2019)

Londonwide LMCS is aware of the increasing complexity and number of information and data sharing agreements (DSAs) and documents which practices are receiving to review and sign. To support practices,...

New CQC guidance section for practices (20 Aug 2019)

In the past 12 months CQC have visited nearly 400 practices in London and found that: 3 were considered outstanding, 300 were considered ‘good’, 57 required improvement, and 23...

Bowel screening update – August 2019 (20 Aug 2019)

NHS England have provided an information sheet to explain the introduction of the faecal immunochemical test (FIT). This replaced the guaiac faecal occult blood test (gFOBt) at the start of...

Tackling social isolation and loneliness to improve health (20 Aug 2019)

Colin Brown, UK Director for Independent Living & Crisis Response at British Red Cross looks at how their expertise will be of use to social prescribing link workers, as they...

Primary care buddying system (20 Aug 2019)

The NHS London Leadership Academy is working with primary care providers to support development in the sector, and to facilitate wider working across the health and social care system. They...

Vaccination update August 2019 (20 Aug 2019)

Hepatitis B in at risk babies Babies born to mothers infected with hepatitis B require a course of hep B vaccination. The first dose is given within 24 hours in...

Londonwide LMCs’ support for Primary Care Network Clinical Directors (20 Aug 2019)

The introduction of the PCN DES means significant changes in the way practices deliver some existing services, and the rolling out of a new range of services. Londonwide LMCs is...

Safeguarding payments and collaborative arrangements (15 Aug 2019)

On 11 July 2019 Dr David Geddes, NHSE/I Director of Primary Care Commissioning, wrote to CCGs and STPs advising that payment for safeguarding activity is not covered by core NHS...

Tips of the month August 2019 (15 Aug 2019)

We provide weekly tips based on common queries which come through to us from London GPs and practice teams. These are shared via social media and collated for...